I don't know why this comparison has been sitting on the back burner for so long for me. Matthew Quick is one of my favorite authors this past year, and
Silver Linings Playbook seriously is my favorite movie in the whole wide world lately. The book and film are quite different, though both wonderful.
I watched the movie on my 31st birthday this year, rented from Redbox. As you all well know by now, Bradley Cooper is amazing in my humble opinion, and I wanted to give Jennifer Lawrence a second chance, since I really didn't care for her much in the first
Hunger Games film (my opinion has since been dramatically changed for the better.) It just so happened that my boyfriend at the time gave me the book the following day for my birthday, which was a total coincidence. The first time I saw the movie though, I knew it was something special. I raced to read the book and read it in one day...again, something special.


Basically, this is the story of Pat. He's a guy who's down and out, after finding out his wife was having an affair, he breaks down and is set to a mental institution instead of jail as his plea bargain with the courts after a minor incident. While there, he finds out that he has had undiagnosed bipolar disorder and has really been white knuckling it for many years. When he gets out, he tries to put together the pieces of his life with his newfound philosophy, that there's a silver lining to every story including his own. Oh yeah, and "Excelsior"...which pretty much means the same thing in his mind. Pat meets Tiffany, a recent widow who is dealing with her own social anxieties and depression in her own ways, and they embark on their journey together. And what a journey it is...
Like I said, there are quite a few differences between the book and movie. In the book, the last names are different, and the story takes place in New Jersey (Philadelphia in the film.) There are a few differences in how things play out, though the round-about story is the same. The same things are achieved in both, just the way that they happen is different in some instances. I don't want to tell too many of the differences, because I don't want to give it away what happens and all...it's something you need to experience yourself. The book is laugh out loud funny, it's heartbreaking, it's so many things...but it is one of my favorite books that I've read this year (just finished reading it a second time tonight.) Fast read, short chapters, amazing.
The film? Wow. Seriously, there was magic made with this. I've seen many postings on Tumblr and comments in interviews that Bradley Cooper (Pat) and Jennifer Lawrence (Tiffany) bring back chemistry on the screen as we know and should expect it, and well...they do. Big time. The whole cast does actually. Robert DeNiro plays Pat's father, and Jacki Weaver plays his mom (based on Bradley Cooper's mom actually in many ways.) They were all nominated for Academy Awards for the film, in every acting category, and while Jennifer was the only one to win (who can forget the gorgeous dress that caused her to trip up the stairs?!), this was the first movie to have this happen in quite a long time. You really feel the family vibe, the good and the bad, ups and downs, and it's wonderful to watch. And watch it I have...easily 50 times since May (probably more if we want to be fully honest here.) It's my feel good movie, whenever I'm down, it's what I watch (sorry Matthew Macfadyen and
Pride and Prejudice, you've been replaced.) Not only for Bradley, but for the whole thing.
Bradley's Pat will make you laugh and cry. There's one scene where he's in his therapist Cliff's office waiting room and has an outburst, and the look on his face afterwards will break your heart, because you know that he knows what's happening and that he doesn't like it and wants to change it, but he doesn't know how. It's a different side of Bradley Cooper than people had been used to, after his stints in
The Hangover trilogy and
Wedding Crashers...but it's something that us fans knew he had in him all along.
Jennifer Lawrence's Tiffany totally rocks my socks when she arrives about 25 minutes into the film as Pat's friend ("with a capital F.") In interviews, everyone says that this character is the most like her, a girl who refuses to play anything similar to herself for fear of losing herself (and she thinks she's boring and would never pay to see her life on screen...ha!) She has so many great scenes, from the diner ("hot!") to where she literally schools Robert DeNiro about Philly sports (all of the facts are correct based on when the story takes place.) She shows so many dimensions to the character right from the beginning that take nearly 200 pages to find in the book.
Robert DeNiro sat down with Bradley Cooper's uncle (Coop is from Philadelphia) to get down the Philly accent, actually making him say each of his lines so that he could fully get it. So many scenes make you want to reach out to Pat Sr. as he himself tries to reach out to his son while dealing with his own OCD issues.
Pat and Tiffany meet for the first time, and well...it's rather awkward.
Now here are a few little tidbits. The soundtrack is great, though if you're going to purchase it, go with the various artists one, not the score. I'm not bashing the score, but it is a circular loop, just like how Pat's mind is working throughout the film. If you buy the various artists soundtrack, you will get the main parts from the score included, and that will be enough for you.
The film was inspired by David O. Russell's son's dealings with bipolar and OCD, and his son appears in each of his movies. (Yup, even
American Hustle where he plays one of Carmine's children.) In this film, he plays a kid from down the street wanting to film Pat's story in a documentary for school. It's an honest film in this area of mental illness, and Bradley Cooper and David O. Russell have both been in Washington DC promoting reform in diagnosing and treating mental illnesses such as bipolar, anxiety, depression, post-traumatic stress, and OCD. There's a scene where Tiffany asks Pat what meds he's on, and while it's funny in their descriptions of how the different medications make them feel, it's true and it can be scary trying to find the right balance in time to help the person affected.
This includes the dinner with Tiffany's sister and brother-in-law who is friends with Pat. Some of the best parts...
Russell is a master at finding the humor in the littlest things, especially family dealings, and much like his other films, you do need to watch the film more than once to get the full effect. Pay attention to the big picture the first time, and then the second time you will notice the small intricacies that make it truly great. For example, pay attention to Jennifer Lawrence's facial expressions during the tour of her sister Veronica's house, or Bradley Cooper's side comments while Tiffany is schooling his dad. If you don't like it after the second trip, then well...I can't help you. Instead, I'll just feel sorry for you.
If you rent it, please try to get the version with deleted scenes (I know some rental copies don't include these.) Especially the extended ending and the rehearsal warm-up sequence. Otherwise, YouTube them after seeing the movie, because it is a pity they weren't included in the final version of the film. (Bradley Cooper attempting to do a back bend alone is worth this extra effort of finding the clip.)
Another book cover...I just love all of the different facial expressions of each character. And I forgot to mention that Chris Tucker does a great job as well as Pat's friend Danny..."black it up, Pat!"
All in all, well...there isn't an all in all. You just have to see it and experience it for yourself. If you want to just watch the movie or just read the book, that's fine. Obviously, I recommend both. It doesn't matter which order you do it in. This is one of those cases though where seeing the movie first helps put a voice to the characters in the book, at least in my opinion. And that way, if you didn't like the movie (after the second try...remember, give it two!) you won't waste your time reading the book. (Though you should read Matthew Quick anyway. He's worth your time.)
Book: 5 stars
Film: 5 stars (duh!)